Why Did The Dodgers Trade Yordan Alvarez? Unpacking The 2016 Deal
Baseball, you know, has a way of creating these moments that fans talk about for years. One particular trade, a move made back in 2016, still gets a lot of discussion among those who follow the game. It involves a player who has since become a true superstar, and the team that let him go. We are, of course, talking about Yordan Alvarez and the Los Angeles Dodgers.
For many fans, the idea of the Dodgers having Yordan Alvarez seems like a dream. He hits the ball with incredible power. He has become a dominant force in the sport. So, it's almost natural to wonder why a team would ever part with such a talent, especially one who was so young at the time.
The answer, you see, is not a simple one. It involves the immediate needs of a team, the uncertain world of prospect evaluation, and a bit of what we call hindsight. Understanding this trade means looking at the situation from both sides, as it appeared in the summer of 2016, not just with what we know today. Frankly, it is a complex story.
Table of Contents
- The Trade Details: What Actually Happened?
- The Dodgers' Perspective at the Time: A Playoff Push
- Yordan Alvarez as a Prospect Then: A Raw Talent
- The Astros' Side of the Deal: Taking a Chance
- The Aftermath and Hindsight: A Star Is Born
- Frequently Asked Questions About the Alvarez Trade
The Trade Details: What Actually Happened?
The trade involving Yordan Alvarez took place on August 1, 2016. This was the deadline for trades without waivers that year. The Los Angeles Dodgers sent a group of players to the Houston Astros. This group included Yordan Alvarez, then a very young minor league player. It also included pitchers Josh Fields and Brayan Hernandez, and another minor league pitcher named Dean Deetz. You know, quite a few names.
In return for these players, the Dodgers received one player back. That player was relief pitcher Josh Fields. He was a right-handed pitcher. He had some experience pitching in the major leagues. The Dodgers needed help in their bullpen for the stretch run of the season. They were pushing for a spot in the playoffs. So, this was a move to address that immediate need.
At the time, Yordan Alvarez was just 19 years old. He had very little professional experience. He had signed with the Dodgers as an international free agent in June 2016. He had played just a few games in rookie ball. This was, in some respects, a quick turnaround for him. He was a raw talent, certainly.
The Dodgers' Perspective at the Time: A Playoff Push
In August 2016, the Dodgers were right in the middle of a race for the playoffs. They had a good team. They had some strong starting pitchers. However, their bullpen, that part of the pitching staff that comes in later in games, needed some help. They wanted to add a reliable arm. Josh Fields was seen as that kind of arm. He had pitched for the Astros for a few seasons. He had shown he could get big league hitters out. That's what they needed right then, frankly.
Baseball organizations often have to make tough choices. They balance the needs of today with the hopes for tomorrow. When a team is trying to win a championship, they might give up a prospect for a player who can help them right away. This is a common strategy. It is a calculated risk. So, the Dodgers were thinking about winning in 2016.
Prospect evaluation is, you know, a really tricky business. Most minor league players, even those with a lot of promise, never become stars. Many do not even reach the major leagues. Yordan Alvarez was a very young player. He had only just begun his professional journey. He was not yet a household name among prospects. He was just a kid with potential, basically.
The Dodgers also had a very strong farm system at that point. They had many other hitting prospects. Players like Cody Bellinger and Alex Verdugo were coming up through their system. These players were closer to being ready for the big leagues. They were, in some respects, more developed. The team likely felt they had enough hitting talent in the pipeline. This could be a factor in their decision. They felt they could spare one young hitter for a bullpen arm. That's how these things often work.
Yordan Alvarez as a Prospect Then: A Raw Talent
When the Dodgers signed Yordan Alvarez in June 2016, he was a highly regarded international free agent from Cuba. He had a reputation for having huge raw power. This means he could hit the ball very far. He had a strong, powerful swing. He was, you know, physically imposing even at a young age.
However, like many young players from international signings, he was still very raw. He had not played much organized baseball in a professional setting. There were questions about his hitting ability against top pitching. People wondered about his defense. They also wondered what position he would play in the field. He was not a polished player by any means. He was still very much a project.
Some scouts, to be honest, did see the incredible upside in Alvarez. They saw the potential for a truly special bat. But others were more cautious. They worried about the risks involved. They wondered if he would ever truly put it all together. This is typical for prospects, especially very young ones. It is not always clear how they will develop. It is a bit of a gamble, sometimes.
At the time of the trade, Alvarez had played just two games in the rookie-level Dominican Summer League. He had only 11 plate appearances. This is a very, very small sample size. It is hard to know much about a player from such limited action. So, the Dodgers were trading a player with immense potential, but also a lot of unknowns. They were trading a lottery ticket, in a way.
The Astros' Side of the Deal: Taking a Chance
The Houston Astros, on the other hand, were in a slightly different position in 2016. They were not quite as close to a championship as the Dodgers. They had a strong farm system. They were willing to take on players with high upside. They could afford to be patient with development. They were, you know, building for the future.
The Astros' scouting department saw something special in Yordan Alvarez. They believed in his raw power. They felt they could help him refine his hitting skills. They were willing to invest the time and resources into his development. They had a good track record of developing young hitters. This was, in fact, a strength of their organization.
For the Astros, giving up Josh Fields was not a huge loss. He was a solid relief pitcher. But they had other options in their bullpen. They were not as desperate for immediate bullpen help as the Dodgers. They were more focused on acquiring long-term talent. So, they saw Alvarez as a valuable addition to their prospect pool. They saw a chance to get a truly special player, in some respects.
This trade, for the Astros, was a classic "buy low" situation. They acquired a player who was not yet widely known. He had not proven himself in professional baseball. They were betting on their ability to develop him. It was a calculated risk, of course, but one that ultimately paid off handsomely for them. They were, you know, looking for hidden gems.
The Aftermath and Hindsight: A Star Is Born
After the trade, Josh Fields pitched for the Dodgers through the 2018 season. He had some good moments, especially during their 2017 playoff run. He was a decent contributor to their bullpen. He did what he was brought in to do. He helped the team in the short term, you know, for a little while.
Meanwhile, Yordan Alvarez began his journey through the Astros' minor league system. He quickly showed why the Astros were so high on him. He dominated at every level. His power was undeniable. His hitting improved significantly. He moved up the ranks very, very quickly. He was clearly a special talent.
Alvarez made his major league debut with the Astros in 2019. He immediately became a sensation. He won the American League Rookie of the Year award. He hit for both average and power. He became one of the most feared hitters in baseball. He was, in fact, an instant star. He helped the Astros reach the World Series that year. He has continued to be a major force for them. He has had MVP-caliber seasons. He was a huge part of their World Series win in 2022. He was, you know, absolutely amazing in that series.
Looking back, this trade is often cited as one of the most lopsided in recent baseball history. The Dodgers got a decent reliever for a few seasons. The Astros got a generational slugger. It is easy to say now that the Dodgers made a mistake. But, you know, decisions are made with the information available at the time. Prospect evaluation is incredibly difficult. Every team has stories of players who got away. The Dodgers still had a lot of success. They won a World Series in 2020. But this trade will always be a "what if" for their fans. It is, you know, just part of baseball history.
You can learn more about Yordan Alvarez on our site. Also, check out this page for more trade analysis. It is interesting to see how these things play out, you know, over time.
When Did The Dodgers Trade Yordan Alvarez? - Metro League
Why Did The Dodgers Trade Yordan Alvarez? - YouTube
Hitting Coach Breaks Down Why The Dodgers Might Have Traded Yordan
